Is AI getting “good enough”?

In two minds about using AI for art works

This is an AI image I created with the prompt above, using google Deep Mind’s latest incarnation of its generative app Imogen-3. it really looks better than most other generative AI. Less overcrowding with intricate but less relevant detail, with consistent lighting and better capturing the emotional direction of my prompt. It was also my only creation with this prompt.

Google claims 

"We’ve significantly improved Imagen 3’s ability to understand prompts, which helps the models generate a wide range of visual styles and capture small details from longer prompts.

To be even more useful, Imagen 3 will be available in multiple versions, each optimized for different types of tasks, from generating quick sketches to high-resolution images."

Ok that’s nice wording google but what does it mean and why do I see such a difference to other prompt generated images

Well perhaps there is a hint right at the end of their hype.

"Imagen 3 was built with our latest safety and responsibility innovations, from data and model development to production.

We used extensive filtering and data labeling to minimize harmful content in datasets and reduced the likelihood of harmful outputs. We also conducted red teaming and evaluations on topics including fairness, bias and content safety.”

Recent developments in AI technology have raised some intriguing questions about data handling, promoting fake news and bias. It appears that at least google is implementing input checking mechanisms on the information they use to train their models. This likely extends to assessing image quality as well, ensuring that the data fed into these systems meets certain standards. Looks “good enough”.

However, this observation leads to a more pressing personal concern: 

Does responsible AI development truly encompass ethical practices across the board? The issue of data collection methods remains a significant point of contention. Are these companies indiscriminately scraping data from various sources without proper consent or consideration?

This brings me to a personal worry many of us share: the privacy of our own data, particularly our photos. With the prevalence of cloud-based photo storage services like Google Photos, and the vast number of images captured and uploaded from mobile devices daily, it's natural to wonder about the security and usage of this data. I worry some companies are "hoovering up" these personal images en masse? If so, what are the implications for our privacy and the control we have over our own digital footprint? 

As consumers and digital citizens, it's important that we stay informed about these practices and advocate for ethical standards in AI development. The balance between technological advancement and personal privacy is delicate, and it's a conversation we need to keep having as AI continues to evolve and integrate into our daily lives.